Why the Rangers Need to Be Wary of Giving Josh Hamilton a Mega-Contract

photo of Josh Hamilton playing.

photo of Josh Hamilton playing. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

Josh Hamilton‘s historic display of offense Tuesday night was simply phenomenal. Regardless of where your baseball loyalties lie, you need to admit his performance was spectacular. Currently Hamilton earns $15.25 million per year. He is one of the premier players in the game. We can safely assume the price tag for his services next season will probably go the route of the Avengers movie and set a new record. Except I have some unsolicited advice for the Rangers, or any team considering a Josh Hamilton courtship: to the buyer beware.

Hamilton, like any player, is a risk. I wonder if his past off-field problems will impact his future. The turnaround in his life is awesome and for that, I commend him. However, any general manager would have to ask themselves whether Hamilton could handle the pressure of a contract similar to the current first baseman for the Angels. Yes, you know where I’m going with this: Albert Pujols. The best word I can use for Pujols right now is funk. He’s in the funk of his career. I believe it’s the pressure of the contract.

Some suggested the contract Pujols signed is a distraction and they are correct. He will come out of it and when he does, I believe “The Machine” will dominate. The question with Hamilton is can he handle that pressure? A very select group of clubs can afford that liability. How many would be willing to? Will the fans demonstrate enough patience?

There are many questions that surround such contracts and the decision-making process. As observers and fans of the game, the public sometimes forgets these players are human. I am not faulting Hamilton for his past, I’m merely stating a reality of life and the business of professional sports. I like to think that Hamilton is emotionally and mentally prepared to assume a role with such scrutiny. I will state it again, he is an amazing talent and a true asset to the game.

In the end, Hamilton will get paid whether he stays in Arlington or goes elsewhere. The question will be whether he can handle the pressure of the mega-contract fishbowl he will find himself swimming in.

Agree? Disagree? Let me know what you think!


4 thoughts on “Why the Rangers Need to Be Wary of Giving Josh Hamilton a Mega-Contract

  1. Pingback: My Baseball Blogging Community and Friends: A Shout-Out | The On Deck Circle

  2. To me it’s not really a matter of if someone should spend money to sign him in the off-season, it’s how much money, and more importantly, for how many years? Anything more than a four or five year deal would be very foolish. I could see 18 million per year over five years, max (90 million), but I’m sure his agent will be looking for 7 or 8 years and closer to 20 million per year.
    Also, he has to know that he currently enjoys the luxury of playing in arguably the best hitter’s park in the A.L. Almost anywhere else he goes will be a more difficult environment for him to play in (despite yesterday’s 4-homer game in Baltimore.)
    But there is no question that he’s an MVP caliber player, so we can’t expect that he’s ever going to settle for a three year deal. Nor should he.
    Nice post,

    • Excellent points Bill. Normally I would say the power lies with the player because of what he can bring to a team. But the Rangers are the best fit for Hamilton. Aside from the hitter’s park point you make, Texas is a perennial powerhouse. Everyone wants to be on a winner. I say 8 years at $20 mil a year. Thanks for the response.


      • I think that’s about what he’ll get, too. But like you, I think that will be a mistake for the team that signs him (probably Texas.)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s