Watching Derek Jeter’s Iconic Career

Derek Jeter

Derek Jeter (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

Previously I posted about the iconic career of Cal Ripken, Jr. Yesterday,  another icon passed Ripken on the all-time hits list. Derek Jeter notched hit 3,185 in the Yankees 14-7 loss to the Chicago White Sox.

You may ask why is this important on the grand scale of baseball history? The answer is simple: we are watching, live, the career of a living legend. Baseball stories revolve around players. All fans have stories about their favorite players, legends in their own time. Mays, Gehrig, Mantle, Ripken himself. Regardless of whether you love or “hate” the Yankees, Jeter is a rare staple of the game. He reached 3,000 hits on a home run. This, after most, including myself, questioned whether he had anything left to give.

The lesson learned is don’t count out an icon. Jeter will leave the game when he is ready. The talk around Jeter changes with the seasons. Now Jeter’s name is mentioned in the same sentence as Pete Rose. Jeter would need an average of 214 hits a season for the next five years to reach 4,256 career hits. Jeter, at 38, may not have the gas needed to continue playing, and hitting until age 43. Is it possible? Anything is possible.

Let’s not crown Jeter just yet. Instead, let’s enjoy his career one day at a time. In case you missed it, here’s a brief run down of Jeter’s career to date:

3,185 Hits

247 HR

.313 BA

Gold Glove 2004, 2005, 2006, 2009, and 2010 (shortstop)

1996 ROY

5 World Series Championships

The Best Shortstop In Cooperstown

Jeter will be a first ballot inductee into the Hall of Fame. However, will he be the best shortstop to enter the hallowed ground of Cooperstown? Honus Wagner, Ozzie Smith, Cal Ripken, John Ward, and several others may object. Intentionally missing from this brief list is a popular HOF member: Phil Rizzuto. My opinion on Rizzuto changed after reading a piece by Bill Miller, author of The On Deck Circle. You can find the current list of Hall of Fame shortstops here.

Statistically Jeter is compiling a compelling argument for best shortstop all-time. Some may contend he played for a perennial winning team. Should championships be considered? Should lack of winning an MVP be considered? What about offensive WAR? OPS+? etc.

The debate over who is the best shortstop, all-time will never be settled. One thing is sure, we are all witness to a legendary career right before our eyes. So sit back, and enjoy. Careers such as this are rare.

All data from,, and


4 thoughts on “Watching Derek Jeter’s Iconic Career

  1. My choice for best short stop of all-time is Honus Wagner, followed by Cal Ripkin, Jr. Alan Trammell would also make my top ten list, as would the seriously underrated Arky Vaughn. Rizzuto is top 25-30. Larkin, A-Rod and Ernie Banks are also on the high end of my top ten, as is, of course, Jeter.
    Thanks so much for mentioning my post comparing Rizzuto and Trammell.
    Gary Templeton was a lot of fun to watch back in the day, but his career took a turn for the worse once he was traded over to San Diego in exchange for some guy named Smith, O. (who is also in the top ten at his position.)
    Cheers, Bill

    • Thanks for the response Bill. Yes, Vaughn seems to be lost to history. My brief research for this post introduced me to Vaughn. It’s a shame that Trammell has yet to be inducted. Good point about Templeton. Your post, and that series is good work and deserves to be shared.


    • As Bill James wrote in his Historical Abstracts, Vaughan’s career doesn’t leave much out. Pretty good defense, good power, excellent on-base skills. Jeter’s a somewhat pastel version of Vaughan (well, if you compare their peaks), but you’ve got to say Jeter is a clear top-five SS of all time, and probably in the top three.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s